8 Secrets for Creating Pop-Ups that Convert Like Crazy!

In partnership with

Find Best Apps for eCommerce || Newsletter

In the fast-paced world of eCommerce, finding ways to capture attention and drive conversions can feel like a balancing act.

One powerful tool in your arsenal? Pop-ups! With the right strategy, pop-ups can grow your email list and boost conversions—without annoying your visitors. But there’s more to it than just throwing up a sign-up box.

Today, we’ll break down the science of creating pop-ups that not only capture attention but turn casual browsers into committed customers. Let’s dive in!

It’s Not Too Late to Drive Black Friday Sales

Black Friday marks the most streamed period of the year on Roku, and Roku Ads Manager makes it easy to reach your audience during this all-important kickoff to the holiday season. Roku’s self-serve platform lets you set up, optimize, and measure CTV campaigns in real-time so you can focus on driving results. Plus, innovative ad formats like Action Ads let viewers instantly engage with your brand and even shop directly on-screen with a click of their remote – perfect for holiday shopping.

Drive Black Friday Performance

1. The One Element Your Popup MUST Have

We all acknowledge the impact of images on conversions—be it on product pages or within emails. But the question remains: can images enhance the effectiveness of pop-ups? In other words, does the inclusion of an image in a popup truly make a difference?

To test our hypothesis, we first looked at 1+ million popup views. Then, we filtered out any popups with 2,000 views or less to ensure our overall conversion rate was valid. Finally, we analyzed (1) popups with images and (2) popups without images. It was found that pop-ups with images (3.80 percent) outperformed their image-less counterparts (2.07 percent).

2. Use This Underused Element to Get More Emails

Much like images, urgency can be a powerful driver of conversions when wielded ethically. The concept of "FOMO" (Fear of Missing Out) pushes fence-sitting buyers to take action.

Enter the countdown timer—an often overlooked element that can inject a sense of urgency into your pop-ups. For this test, we first reviewed 1+ million popup views. Then, we filtered out any popups with 2,000 views or less to ensure we had a valid overall conversion rate. Finally, we looked at (1) popups with a countdown timer and (2) popups without a countdown timer. It was discovered that popups featuring countdown timers (8.07 percent) outperformed those without (3.79 percent).

3. Input Fields: What You Need to Know

Growing your email list involves a delicate balance between acquiring valuable information and not overwhelming potential subscribers. The common assumption is that fewer input fields equate to higher conversions.

For this test, we looked at 1 million popup views. Then, we filtered out any popups with 2,000 views or less to ensure our overall conversion rate was valid. Finally, we analyzed the conversion rate for popups with one, two, three, four, and five input fields. Popups with five input fields had the lowest conversion rate (0.81 percent), only marginally less than those with four fields (0.90 percent). The real revelation, however, was that popups with two input fields (3.31 percent) outperformed those with three (1.08 percent) by an astonishing 206.48 percent.

4. How to Enrich Lead Data: Multiple Steps (The Right Way)

Enriching lead data while maintaining conversions can be a tightrope walk for marketers. Enter the Multistep feature. The premise is simple: capture email addresses in the first step and follow up with additional data requests without losing the lead if the popup is closed.

Testing the hypothesis on input fields, it was discovered that 76 percent of subscribers willingly provided more information in the second step. This opens the door for enriching lead data without deterring conversions.

5. Use a Timed Trigger?

Timed Triggers offer an intriguing way to display pop-ups based on a visitor's time spent on a webpage. But finding the optimal trigger time can be a challenge. Research indicated that popups triggered after eight seconds (3.62 percent) yielded superior conversions compared to other trigger times.

6. Desktop vs. Mobile: Which Is Better?

With mobile traffic on the rise, the question arose: do mobile or desktop popups fare better? To our astonishment, mobile popups (5.8 percent) trumped desktop (3.11 percent) in terms of conversions. This suggests the importance of tailoring campaigns to specific devices for enhanced results.

7. The Power of Teasers in Your Popups!

Instead of bombarding your visitors with information right away, use the power of curiosity. A teaser popup is a mini popup that shows up before or after the main popup. It increases the popup visibility up to 65% and works as a minimal version of your campaign.

8. The Playful Path to Conversions: Gamified Popups

Enter gamified popups, the secret weapon of attention-grabbing. These popups infuse an element of interactivity, making the user experience more entertaining and memorable. Whether it's a spin-to-win wheel, a scratch-off card, or a clever quiz, gamified popups create an immersive experience that keeps users intrigued and excited.

When users feel like they're participating in a fun activity rather than just encountering a marketing message, they're more likely to stick around, interact, and convert. It's a win-win situation: you provide value and entertainment, and they reward you with their engagement.

Pop-ups, when used thoughtfully, can be game-changers for your eCommerce business.

With the right combination of visuals, urgency, and a dash of fun, you can transform the user experience and drive meaningful engagement. So, are you ready to put these tips into action? We’re excited to see your conversions soar!

Until next time, happy optimizing!

P.S. – If you found these insights helpful, don't hesitate to share with a friend, or hit 'reply' to share your own pop-up experiences and results. We'd love to hear from you!