Why Your Subscribers Aren’t Clicking—And How to Change That

In partnership with

Find Best Apps for eCommerce || Newsletter

Subject lines and design can only take you so far—what really drives conversions is how your audience feels when they read your emails. If something seems unclear or uncertain, they’re more likely to hesitate and move on.

That’s where the Ambiguity Effect comes in. People naturally avoid unclear choices, so the secret to higher engagement? Make your emails crystal clear. Today, I’m sharing 10 proven ways to reduce uncertainty in your emails and get your subscribers to take action faster.

What is the Ambiguity Effect?

The ambiguity effect refers to our tendency to avoid options that are unclear or lack sufficient information. We have a natural dislike for uncertainty, which makes us more likely to choose options with known probabilities of favorable outcomes.

How Does the Ambiguity Effect Apply to Your Emails?

In simple terms, the ambiguity effect leads people to steer clear of uncertain choices, favoring clear and familiar options instead. In email marketing, this means that the clearer and more straightforward your message, the more likely your subscribers are to take action.

Whether it’s clicking a link, using a promo code, or signing up for an event, your audience needs to know exactly what to expect!

Why This Matters for Your Emails

The goal is simple: we want our subscribers to feel confident in what we’re offering. By understanding the ambiguity effect, you can write emails that make it easy for them to decide. The less they have to think or guess, the more likely they are to engage with your content.

Unlock New Growth on Amazon

Growing on Amazon takes more than great products—it’s about getting in front of the right shoppers. With affiliate marketing, you can:

✅ Drive high-quality traffic – Reach shoppers off Amazon by partnering with 8K+ vetted publishers, affiliates, and influencers.
✅ Control your commissions – Set CPA or CPC by product or creator to maximize ROI.
✅ Boost organic rankings – Amazon rewards external traffic with better search visibility and a 10% kickback.

Download the Guide

How Can You Use It in Your Emails?

Here are 8 ways to apply the ambiguity effect to your email marketing.

1. Make Your CTA Super Clear

Your call to action (CTA) is one of the most crucial parts of your email. It should be direct and leave no room for confusion. Instead of vague phrases like “Learn More” or “Discover,” try “Shop Now” or “Get 20% Off Today!” Specificity guides your subscribers toward the desired action.

Example:
Nike uses clear CTAs like “Shop Women’s Best Sellers” and “Get Your Gear Now.” These phrases help readers know what to expect, leading to higher engagement.

2. Reduce Uncertainty

To make your emails more effective, aim to reduce uncertainty. Here are some ways to do that:

• Keep It Simple: Use clear, easy-to-understand language that tells your audience exactly what you’re offering.

• Highlight the Benefits: Be upfront about what your subscribers will gain. If you’re offering a discount, specify the amount they’ll save. If it’s new content, explain its value.

• Show Social Proof: Incorporate testimonials, reviews, or user-generated content to build trust. Seeing positive experiences from others encourages readers to take action.

Example:
Ghostbed effectively includes customer reviews, such as '20,000 positive reviews.' This social proof reduces doubt and encourages readers to try the product themselves

3. Use Curiosity—But Don’t Overdo It!

Now, I know I just said clarity is key, but a little curiosity can also be a good thing—especially in your subject lines. You want to grab your readers’ attention without confusing them.

For example, instead of saying “Spring Sale Starts Now,” you could say “Unlock Your Exclusive Spring Deals.” It creates a bit of mystery while still letting them know there’s a sale waiting for them.

4. Highlight the Benefits Right Away

Tell subscribers what they’ll gain by clicking. Whether it’s saving money or accessing exclusive deals, make the benefits obvious.

Example: In an email from ASOS, they quickly state, '20% off on everything,' making the benefit clear right from the subject line. This approach makes it easy for the reader to see what's in it for them.

5. Craft Clear and Honest Subject Lines

Avoid clickbait or overly vague subject lines. Be clear and honest about what your subscribers will find inside the email.

Example: Everlane uses straightforward subject lines like '20% Off + Free Expedited Shipping,' which immediately tell the reader what to expect.

6. Offer Guarantees to Reduce Risk

Adding guarantees, such as “Free Returns” or “Money-Back Guarantee,” can help ease any hesitation about purchasing. When customers know they can return an item if they’re not satisfied, they’re more likely to take the plunge.

Example:
Zappos highlights their “365-day returns” in their emails. This reassurance builds trust and encourages conversions by making customers feel secure in their purchases.

7. Be Transparent About Next Steps

Let your subscribers know what will happen after they click or take action, so there’s no guessing. This clarity helps alleviate uncertainty and builds confidence in your communication.

Example: HelloFresh clearly states the benefits: a significant discount and a lasting offer. This transparency encourages recipients to click through, as they understand what they can gain by engaging with the email.

8. Simplify Your Email Design

A clean, well-organized email design helps guide readers’ attention and reduces decision fatigue. Avoid cluttered layouts that could overwhelm your audience. Instead, focus on a simple design that emphasizes your main message and CTA.

Example:
Apple maintains a sleek, minimalist email design with big images and clear CTAs like “Order Now.” This straightforward approach helps readers focus on what’s important without feeling lost.

9. Use Curiosity Strategically

Use curiosity in subject lines or teaser text to make readers want to learn more, but give them enough info to know what they’re getting into.

Example: Dollar Shave Club uses curiosity with "Don't Miss Out Again," sparking interest while hinting at exclusive offers.

10. Leverage Time-Limited Offers

Create a sense of urgency with limited-time promotions. Clearly state the expiration date to encourage quick action.

Example: Williams Sonoma sends an email saying, “Get 30% Off – Today Only!” This clear deadline prompts immediate engagement from subscribers who don’t want to miss out.

Easy Tips to Get Started

Ready to start using the ambiguity effect in your emails? Here are some quick tips:

• Write Clear, Direct Copy: Be straightforward. Your audience doesn’t want to wade through long, confusing paragraphs to figure out what you’re offering. Get to the point!

• Design for Clarity: Keep your email design simple and easy to navigate. Use headers, bullet points, and images to make your message clear.

• Test It Out: A/B testing is your best friend here. Try out different versions of your emails—one with a clear CTA and another with a slightly ambiguous one. See what resonates best with your audience, and don’t be afraid to tweak things based on the results!

Wrapping It All Up

At the end of the day, clarity builds trust, and trust drives action. By applying the Ambiguity Effect, you can make your emails easier to understand—and harder to ignore.

Try these strategies in your next email campaign and see the difference for yourself! Have any favorite tactics of your own? Hit reply and let me know—I’d love to hear what’s working for you.